Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Steve Wolf's avatar

What you have written is very wise, and I wish more people would talk about the value of "isolation" -- or productive aloneness, as I tend to call it. Part of the problem is a lot of mental health clinicians are compulsively gregarious individuals that like to romanticize community. So they tend to see any kind of social withdrawal as concerning.

I'm more than capable of having a wild social life -- and I have -- but it was only when I embraced aloneness and finally faced myself that I really started to become authentic.

There's a great book I've read -- more than once -- called "Party of One: The Loners' Manifesto" by Anneli Rufus. She's brilliant. She talks about how loners are constantly pathologised by professionals. When the police are hunting for a rapist or murderer, some psychologist is often by their side muttering darkly that this deviant they're pursuing is most likely a "loner" -- that aberrant, fearful thing.

I do feel empathy though for highly tribalistic, extroverted people: despite the value of time spent alone, they don't require much solitude before they start getting serious cabin fever and start climbing the walls. Covid demonstrated that for very social individuals too much alone time is a recipe for mental illness.

I've never had CPTSD -- I'm not sure how I managed that one as I've certainly experienced the ingredients for that condition. Mind you, I've encountered other negative sequelae resulting from classic CPTSD precursors.

So whatever it is that ails you, and if you have the sort of temperament that will benefit from it, "isolation" is very healthy and productive. The other great fringe benefit of not having people in your face all the time is that when you do spend time in the streets and catch up with people you feel a real love and appreciation of humanity, just the bizarre miracle of the human project.

Expand full comment
anon emous's avatar

It's so true, even if they're having an attitude or being a little weirdo, animals are just so honest and good.

Even if they steal a chip off your plate, they do it honestly! 🤣

Expand full comment
33 more comments...

No posts